So what? Let's just say that he's renowned as the best swordsman there is. Such as running for three days/nights without stopping, Were'nt they also being pushed back by Saruman's invisible force that was being used to slow them down?[/QUOTE]. Jaime's skill paired with his armor means he could stand his ground for a long while and take a good amount of hits before going down. That's how tolkien writes though, it's mythos, couldn't be more different to GOT really so comparing feats is a bit unfair. Boromir would be a better match, and even then stomps Jaime Lannister. He is one of the best swordsman in all Westeros, maybe not up to the legends like Ser Barristan Selmy but definitely on par with the likes of Sandor Clegane or Robert Baratheon. George RR Martin on Jaime vs Aragorn: Who Would Win? White walkers are no simple human either, still one was killed by a Sam. He's also 88 and still going strong, a swordsman beyond compare, and a general badass. Sorry Jaime, you'd give him a good fight, but you'd loose. 6. What a reach. At one point he is in a very weakened state with his hands bound and he fights another expert swordsman, later the person he was fighting admits they could barely hold there own against him. Who would win Aragorn vs Jaime Lannister? - Forum Games - A Forum of Also, relevant is that Aragorn is also a master archer due to extensive training and experience fig Continue Reading Quora User On a early Sunday morning (2:00am) a fully armored and fully equipped Kingslayer works his way up to Aragorn's chambers with the intention of killing him. As a descendant of Nmenor, an ancient and powerful race of men, Aragorn has the gift of increased strength, wisdom and life. I think the exception was Balerion the dread, who was ludicrously large. Winner: Aragorn Despite most match-up discussions favoring Aragorn by a landslide, it would likely be a much closer fight than people realize. Aragorn was arguably the strongest man in the entire world. They don't possess great skill with a blade by any stretch of the imagination. Redditors unable to follow the [sub's rules](http://www.reddit.com/r/gameofthrones/w/posting_policy) are banned. What Ranger is capable of? And on the point of Anduril, hey if you're going that route, how about you quantify the properties of Sauron's hand? She defeats a few sellswords -- not a stellar accomplishment. It operates as a normal sword for the entire story. edit: debuffsz tek att :) jaime lannister'in dizide kl ustaln ok grmedik ama kitaplarnda felaket iyi bir sava diye bahsediliyordu. Also, cleaving helmets, while rare like hell, is not unheard of IRL. This is so obvious it hurts. He has excellent endurance and stamina, true, but that's only going to help him if he can stand up to Jaime's skill with a blade. No it's not good enough for me because the materials going into the making of the armor are not taken into account. With the loss of his great skill, he must redefine himself completely. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. In the end, while Jaime is considered to be one of the great swordsmen in Westeros, Aragorn is considered to be the greatest Man in all of Middle-Earth. Aragorn vs Jaime Lannister. - community.cbr.com Being able to take on savage Urak-hai, orcs, & etc isn't even close to the same thing as being able to take on the Kingslayer. you mean book Aragorn who ran in full armor for 3 days and nights or more without stopping or sleepingwhen the three companions covered several hundred miles? Martin writes as Malory wrote Le Morte D'Arthur More about Knights.. More about kings. This is spot on. Jaime lannister. You have nothing to back your claim that kingslayer has an equipment advantage. He engages in battle with the Ma He has a few that are really good, but Aragorn has ten times as many that are just as impressive. Poking fun atAragorn,Martin says, "Armor was invented for a reason. Stealth is only useful if the enemy hasn't seen you yet. Ser Selmy at one point talks of Jaime being the best natural swordsman that he's ever seen. He was already 88 during the events of LOTR Louis Cyphre King of Space May 17, 2014 #15 Aragorn is a old man. It may not display this or other websites correctly. What we do know of Aragorn is this -- he has battled orcs and goblins, Urak-hai and Ringwraiths, and has fought and led Men into numerous battles, both large and small, including the Battle of the Hornburg and the Battle of the Pelennor Fields. I don't know if I agree, but it was an interesting perspective nonetheless. Nouveau sujet Liste des sujets. But, it would seem that his accomplishments -- not Aragorn's -- are the ones that are lacking. Because of the Numenor blood, he's faster, stronger, more resilient and can live longer than any other man. Lannister is good but with that many years of experience I don't see him beating Aragorn. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. While wearing no armor can make you more dexterous, it's a good point that Aragorn is at a disadvantage for never wearing any. He is excellent swordsman and, often he fought against superior numbers of enemy soldiers. With taking courses involving film, Ben has extensive knowledge of movies both new and old, and keeps up to date on all the latest goings-on in the film industry. His incredible skill with a sword is quite instrumental to his character. It is stated in the books that Aragorn is not a simple human. Lord of the Rings' Aragorn and GOT's Jaime Lannister are among the best swordsmen in each of their franchises, but which one would win in a fight? KEEP READING: Lord of the Rings: Why Russell Crowe Turned Down the Aragorn Role. Now, I don't mean to belittle this accomplishment since the very fact that he was maimed makes it impressive. But he doesn't and you don't. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Aug 12, 2016 #25 "The things I do for love. Jaime Lannister Aragorn'dan yi Bir Silahr m?-13 yanda bir turnuva kavgasn kazand.-15 yanda Glmseyen valye ile vs att.-15 yanda Arthur Dayne tarafndan valye ilan edildi.-15 yanda Gerold Hightower tarafndan kral muhafz yapld ve en gen kral muhafz oldu. Enemies he fought he fought not only large groups of Goblins and Orcs, he fought Uruk-Hai and even Nazguls, including Witch King himself . There is nothing, yet, to suggest that she is. You don't happen to have a link? So since there is at LEAST that difference between our world and the other two, you are totally assuming there are no other differences at play. No matter which franchise is preferred, there's no denying each swordsman's skill, as both of them rank as one of the top fighters of their respective franchises. Besides, both Tolkien and Martin are pedantically consistent about their worlds, and they both match the periods they were based on pretty good. Aragorn vs. Jaime Lannister: Who Is the Greater Fantasy Swordsman? Game of thrones is Far more human level than most shows.. while Aragorn was stepped on by a troll and still fought back, and in fights, what, 50 uruk hai? Of course GRRM will say Jaime wins, but at the end of the day Jaime is still only human. Book versions of both, I used the movie pictures to give them a face. Thus he must have had the physical stats to keep up with an Elf who I believe were confirmed to be reasonably faster then humans. Jaime nearly overwhelms an expert swordsman while under severe handicap. Besides, I think Tolkien can be quite hyperbolic with things like that; his, strength of character, etc, was above that of most men, I think that was more. Throughout the courses, he has worked on a number of short films and documentaries. My point is that, magical or not, Anduril isn't going to just cut through Jaime's sword and armor because, surprise, Aragorn doesn't go around cutting through other people's swords and armors in the books. Doubtful as Mithril is pretty damn rare but as I said in my last post: in a 1v1 fight platemail is far inferior to chainmail as it was invented to stop high powered long rang weapons (crossbows, longbows etc..) thus sacrificing agility and speed. GERALT - 0:18ARAGORN - 2:48FIGHT BREAKDOWN - 5:00FOLLOW ME!- INSTAGRAM - https://www.instagram.com/danielturner_danco/Now both Geralt and Aragorn are two of . Everything about him boils down to assumption and theory. He shoves Frodo over the edge of the lookout. Winner: Aragorn Jaime's skill paired with his armor means he could stand his ground for a long while and take a good amount of hits before going down. Argumentez View complete answer on reddit.com Aragorn successfully fighting Nazguls: And that means absolutely nothing since he said book versions of both. Aragorn is just cruel. Come on guys. He even goes on to say Smaug would defeat most of his dragons, despite being smaller than most of them once full grown, due to Smaug having human intelligence. 31 mai 2022 18:21:15. Jaime Lannister Vs Aragorn | FanVerse Why do you keep bringing up tracking, knowledge about herbs and other crap that doesn't apply to this fight. The reason why Aragorn's swordsmanship was not discussed thoroughly as much as Jaime's is because of Tolkien's style of writing compared to Martin.Tolkien's plots (especially in 3rd age) do not regularly show duels and such. Whilethis gives Aragornthe upper hand, his natural-born advantage doesn't necessarily equate to skill. i actually did i it said no results :/ sorry then. It's known that Aragorn has survived battles with thousands of men and orcs, yet little is said about his one on one fights with other skilled swordsmen. Jaime, pre ASOS has no honor, and in a battle, that could actually be a good thing. Boromir is also Numenorean. He's making a joke about another of Viggo Mortenson's roles. Neither does vast knowledge of stealth, tracking, or healing herbs. With such a disadvantage he was still more than a match for an excellent swordsman, imagine if he'd been in a heathly state at the time. Add to that his numerous tourney victories, and the tales of his exploits in previous campaigns, it illustrates quite clearly that Jaime is one of, if not the best swordsman in the GoT's world. My vote goes to him simply because his physical stats are higher (due to him running for 3 days straight) and he used to train with Legolas. All we have is theory and guesswork. Not to mention his reputation for fighting is known all over the land. Take his fight with Brienne, for example. That gives no spoilers away; it is simple truth. That's called being logical. But Jaime Lannister is one of the best ever. With the loss of his great skill, he must redefine himself completely. Supposedly Book Aragorn doesn't have superhuman physical attributes and if Jaime's wearing plate, that's another point in his favor. It would be a good bit closer. No one is saying BookAragorn is an average fighter; he's pretty much exceptional, even more with Andril. The only things that are going to matter in this fight are skill with a blade, and endurance. No, we don't need to guess because we know that it gives him greatly increase stamina - he run for three days without rest, withouth food and water and he wasn't even tired after that. Aragorn destroys Jaime. Boromir, Ned was never a good fighter he was just a good commander. It's hard to explain without spoiling things. This, this and this. Rpondre. Jamie=Kingslayer. Who would win in a fight between Arthur Dayne, Barristan Selmy - Quora Jaime is a foe who has extensively studied the blade and is said by many characters to be extremely skilled. TaintedScholar_of_Midgard 7.2e+82 spells per day. He isn't even the best swordsman in the books. And no, Jaime doesn't have anything approaching Aragorn's endurance feats. And if Jaime were to strike just one heavy blow on Aragorn, it could possiblyleave a lethal wound. Aragorn is descended from Luthien, and therefore Melian, so he does literally have an angel in his ancestry. Le grand Aragorn ne peut pas perdre contre un pseudo chevalier incestueux. Jaime Lannister Vs Aragorn | FanVerse Anduril doesn't give Aragorn any sort of advantage. The only thing we really have to get a sense of Aragorns skill is the foes he's faced, everything else is irrelavent. Depends. what were aragorn's stats again? Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. These are two different characters from two different worlds. I've got to go with Aragorn as well.unless your talking about the Kingslayer from the books. Aragorn has better endurance, but Jaime has better skill. Of course GRRM will say Jaime wins, but at the end of the day Jaime is still only human. For The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt on the PlayStation 4, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Aragorn and Jaime Lannister vs Geralt" - Page 6. If he had access to a Valerian steel sword, possibly you would have a point. For those who don't know in the LOTR books leaders like Aragorn have the power to inspire others, push back dark will, and fight better, in Aragorn's case this comes from his kingly blood. Saying they are (in your opinion) based on two different time periods of earth history has nothing to do with who has superior equipment. According to the source material, who was the better What do you think had happened to Daario Naharis since My brother is watching The Rains of Castamere later today Press J to jump to the feed. When debating this match-up, the most common argument made for Aragorn's victory is his bloodline. You are using an out of date browser. If Jamie is wearing plate mail and Aragorn is wearing chain then Aragorn has a big advantage as chainmail is lighter, more maneuverable and blocks sword blows just as well as plate. To the death!!! That's exactly my point, Tolkien didn't give us much of anything to gauge his skill with. Most of Jaime's sword fighting ability is implied by the dialogue from the characters, not as much by what he actually does in the books. It's good to wear armor if you're fighting with sharp pieces of metal.". Jaime doesn't have enough feats to put him at Aragorn's levels. Dunno about book Jamie but unless he can fight for a night without tiring he to gets stomped I was going by the literary version in my post. I call it being logical. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TwRix1p9sDY. Qui putain de gagne ? The key would be that he lacks 'hero powers' like Aragon and his brother Faramir. In earlier books he is a much different hand to hand combatant than in later books. DCs Grossest Power Ring Is Terrifyingly Strong - But Where Did It Go? Still can't get over the fact that this is the same For everyone who is currently rewatching GoT. Aragorn and Jaime Lannister vs Geralt - The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - GameFAQs Who would win: Aragorn or Jaime Lannister? - Quora - page 2 - Topic Aragorn vs Jaime Lannister du 31-05-2022 18:21:15 sur les forums de jeuxvideo.com. [SPOILERS book J] COTF have to bring a ring to the Doom of Valyria. Both are works placed in a medieval setting, therefore they will have weapons and armor made out of medieval materials. Uruk-Hai are nothing special, their fighting technique consists of being strong and hacking at things with a sword. It's irrelevant. Aragorn, Gimli & Legolas vs Jaime Lannister, The Viper & Jon Snow Tell this to any Batman fan and he would eat you alive. Worse yet, Jaime is 42 years old. Aragorn has Numenor blood, which gives him incredible power. In The Lord of the Rings, however, we see Aragorn ride into several real battles and face numerous foes and come out unscathed. You're right that much of the debate surrounding Aragorn rests on assumptions and theories. All Aragorn did was hack up a bunch of no skill grunts. Aragorn would fuck Jaime up. In his spare time, Ben is usually watching movies, playing games and running D&D games for friends (and hopes to one day actually be a player). It affects the character on a profound level. Postcard from beyond the wall (Saw on FB). The fact that Aragorn doesn't go through the books breaking other swords and shields willy nilly suggests that Anduril is not as powerful as you make it to be. Aragorn wins no less than a solid majority, but it's not easy, as they are both exceedingly talented. He didn't really fight the Nazguls, he just surprised them and drove them off with fire. Aragorn as an old man can probably man-handle peak Jamie. You're nitpicking because you're trying to make the works something they're not. Again, I don't know of any reference to super/metahuman attributes and I've read pretty much all Tolkien has to offer (i'd be open to the suggetion though) Tolkien was always quite vauge with these things. Gandalf mentions something about him being able to lead men well but not with any help from some inner magic. I'm not going to argue this, because -- as I said -- I don't even necessarily agree with it myself. He undoubtedly has excellent precisionand control when weaving through a hoard but facing down an expert fighter with no distractions is a much different circumstance than he seems used to. Jaime is peak human at best. If you want, I'll PM you the rants in question. It was the fire that made them flee, not any skill on Aragorns part. Look where you are asking dude haha. Page suivante Fin. I don't recall any fight with Ringwraiths other than the one on Weathertop, and that was hardly a real fight.